Can I Substitute Butter For Oil In Brownie Mix 

Introduction

Did you run out of oil for your brownie mix batter? Do you have butter? Have no fear, in this article, I’m going to rest your fears—and tastebuds, really—with information on substituting butter for oil in brownies, and if it’s really even possible without ruining the brownies.

It is plausible to substitute butter for oil in brownie mix! It may alter the consistency of the brownies a little. Butter is more preferable to provide aeration for the brownie batter that aids in allowing the brownies to rise. Oil is normally used to make thicker, more fudgy brownies. This doesn’t mean your brownies will end up dry and bland when using butter instead! With oil, they’ll be all-around more extra moist compared to a combination of crisp edges and gooey insides when using butter as a replacement. 

Jump to Recipe

5 Vegan Brownie Mix Brands

 substitute butter for oil

Partake Foods, Brownie Mix 

Free from the top 8 allergens, including dairy and gluten, Partake Foods Brownie Mix is a safe and delicious treat to consume, making it the perfect treat to bring to potlucks or celebrations! It requires only two extra ingredients (water and oil) to be combined with the brownie mix, making it a simple and easy baker’s delight. 

Foodstirs Keto Dry Baking Mix, Chocolate Brownie

Are you living a low-carb lifestyle? Do you miss the delight of eating ooey-gooey chocolate brownies? Look no further!

Check out this Keto Dry Baking Mix of Chocolate Brownies by Foodstirs. This brownie mix contains only 2g of net carbs and 0g of added sugar per serving. It’s also made with non-GMO ingredients and Certified Fair Trade chocolate, adding even healthier ingredients to the mix (pun slightly intended).

Renewal Mill, Dark Chocolate Brownie Mix

Renewal Mill’s Dark Chocolate Brownie Mix features upcycled ingredients like okara flour, which is made from pulp created during soy beverage production. Placing an emphasis on planet-friendly ingredients and products, Renewal Mills is not only an ethical choice but a delicious choice with their fudgy brownies! 

Lakanto, Sugar-free Brownie Mix

Sweetened with monk fruit, a zero-calorie and zero-glycemic index sweetener, Lakanto’s Sugar-free Brownie Mix is like no other with its absence of artificial sweeteners. This brownie mix is gluten-free, keto-friendly, and vegan! 

Simple Mills, Almond Flour Brownie Mix

A best-selling gluten-free brand, Simple Mills has done it again with their Almond Flour Brownie Mix! This brownie mix is gluten-free, vegan, and non-GMO project verified, making it not only a delicious vegan alternative but a healthy one, too.

What You Will Need To Make Brownie Mix With Butter (Instead Of Oil)

Ingredients:

Equipment:

  • Brownie Pan
  • Oil Spray (To Grease Brownie Pan)
  • Spatula (To Scoop Out Brownie Batter)
  • Whisk
  • Measuring Cup
  • Small Microwave-safe Bowl
  • Mixing Bowl 

Step By Step Instructions

Step 1: Preheat The Oven

Following the instructions on the back of the box of Partake Foods Brownie Mix, preheat the oven to 350 F. This can help save time as, depending on the oven, it can take time for the oven to preheat. While the oven is preheating, the proceeding steps will be to make the brownie mix. 

Step 2: Gather Your Supplies

Gather all of the ingredients and supplies needed to make this Brownie Mix With Butter (And No Oil) recipe. 

Step 3: Measure And Melt The Butter

As this recipe will be replacing oil with butter, we will need to melt the butter before it goes into the brownie mix batter. First, measure out the butter using the same ratio of oil to butter. In this case, that will be ¾ cup butter.

After measuring out ¾ cup, place the butter in a microwave-safe bowl. Heat in the microwave in time ratios of 20 seconds until butter is completely melted.

Step 4: Combine Water and Butter

Measure out the water to ½ cup and combine with melted butter in a mixing bowl. 

Step 5: Add Brownie Mix

Add the brownie mix to the mixing bowl along with the mixture of water and melted butter. Stir and combine thoroughly. 

Step 6: Grease Pan And Pour Contents

Grease the brownie pan with oil spray. Pour brownie batter into the brownie pan using the spatula to get leftover batter stuck to the bowl. Spread batter evenly in brownie pan. 

Step 7: Bake

Bake brownie contents for 25-30 minutes. Make sure to check on the brownies, using a toothpick in the center of the pan (the toothpick should come out clean with no batter marring it). 

Step 8: Let Cool And Enjoy!

Once the brownies are done, let them cool before cutting. Enjoy your brownies made with butter instead of oil! 

Tips And Tricks

Use parchment paper to prevent the brownies from sticking to the pan. For all those that have made brownies, cleaning up the brownie batter that sticks like tar to the brownie pan is not a fun endeavor after enjoying decadent brownies (but sometimes it’s the price we must pay). That’s why, instead of suffering through greasing and grinding to clean the brownie pan afterward, simply add parchment paper to the pan and then add the brownie batter for a simple and easy trick to stress-free cleaning!

Metal pans cook brownies faster. Glass pans take longer to cook brownies. Isn’t that an interesting tip? Try it, you’ll be surprised! 

 substituting butter for oil in brownies

Servings And Preparation Time

Preparation Time  Cook Time Servings
5 Minutes 25-30 Minutes 19 (Per Container)

Conclusion

Did you enjoy this recipe? Make sure to leave a comment below to tell us what you think or if you have any questions. Don’t forget to share this informational guide Substituting Butter For Oil In Brownie Mix and tag us on social media! 

We would love to see your finished ooey-gooey brownies. Tell us which vegan brownie mix you used and how your brownies turned out! 

Brownie Mix With Butter (Instead Of Oil)

Best Vegan Tips
Prep Time 5 mins
Cook Time 30 mins
Total Time 35 mins
Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Servings 19

Equipment

  • Brownie Pan
  • Oil Spray (To Grease Brownie Pan)
  • Spatula (To Scoop Out Brownie Batter)
  • Whisk
  • Measuring Cup
  • Small Microwave-safe Bowl
  • Mixing Bowl

Ingredients
  

  • 1 Box Brownie Mix Try Partake Foods Brownie Mix
  • ½ Cup Water
  • ¾ Cup Oil Replace with ¾ Cup Melted Butter (Try Earth Balance Buttery Spread)

Instructions
 

  • Following the instructions on the back of the box of Partake Foods Brownie Mix, preheat the oven to 350 F. This can help save time as, depending on the oven, it can take time for the oven to preheat. While the oven is preheating, the proceeding steps will be to make the brownie mix.
  • Gather all of the ingredients and supplies needed to make this Brownie Mix With Butter (And No Oil) recipe.
  • As this recipe will be replacing oil with butter, we will need to melt the butter before it goes into the brownie mix batter. First, measure out the butter using the same ratio of oil to butter. In this case, that will be ¾ cup butter.
  • After measuring out ¾ cup, place the butter in a microwave-safe bowl. Heat in the microwave in time ratios of 20 seconds until butter is completely melted.
  • Measure out the water to ½ cup and combine with melted butter in a mixing bowl.
  • Add the brownie mix to the mixing bowl along with the mixture of water and melted butter. Stir and combine thoroughly.
  • Grease the brownie pan with oil spray. Pour brownie batter into the brownie pan using the spatula to get leftover batter stuck to the bowl. Spread batter evenly in brownie pan.
  • Bake brownie contents for 25-30 minutes. Make sure to check on the brownies, using a toothpick in the center of the pan (the toothpick should come out clean with no batter marring it).
  • Once the brownies are done, let them cool before cutting. Enjoy your brownies made with butter instead of oil!

Notes

Use parchment paper to prevent the brownies from sticking to the pan. For all those that have made brownies, cleaning up the brownie batter that sticks like tar to the brownie pan is not a fun endeavor after enjoying decadent brownies (but sometimes it's the price we must pay). That’s why, instead of suffering through greasing and grinding to clean the brownie pan afterward, simply add parchment paper to the pan and then add the brownie batter for a simple and easy trick to stress-free cleaning!
Keyword can i substitute butter for oil in brownie mix, substitute butter for oil, substitute butter for vegetable oil, substituting butter for oil in brownies

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating